birthday traffic

What happens to births on Labor Day and Thanksgiving?

Published by Birthday Traffic · · Sources and method

A fixed holiday like December 25 is easy to spot in a birthday ranking, because it is always the same date. Labor Day and Thanksgiving fall on a different date each year, so their effect is spread across several dates. Measured against same-weekday control days in the same year, both record fewer births than those control days in every one of the 21 years.

Labor Day

Labor Day is the first Monday in September, under the federal holiday rule published by the U.S. Office of Personnel Management. The dates below are derived from that rule in code.

Across the 21 years, Labor Day recorded 171,820 births where its control days averaged 261,059 over the same number of days: a ratio of 65.8% of the control level, a difference of 89,239 recorded births between the two sets of days. Year by year the ratio ranges from 60.4% to 73.2%, averaging 66.0%, and it is below the control level in 21 of 21 years. The difference is between two sets of recorded days.

Labor Day: births as a percentage of its matched control days, by year

Twenty-one columns, 1994 to 2014, each the holiday’s births against the mean of its same-weekday control days that year, with 100 drawn as a line.

Labor Day: births as a percentage of its matched control days, by yearTwenty-one columns, 1994 to 2014, each the holiday’s births against the mean of its same-weekday control days that year, with 100 drawn as a line.0204060801001994: 72.5%19941995: 73.2%73.2%1996: 72.1%1997: 71.7%19971998: 72.7%1999: 70.7%2000: 70.2%20002001: 65.6%2002: 66.2%2003: 64.2%20032004: 65.9%2005: 62.6%2006: 62.0%20062007: 61.8%2008: 60.4%60.4%2009: 60.9%20092010: 62.5%2011: 62.0%2012: 63.1%20122013: 62.9%2014: 63.5%100 = control days
Labor Day against matched control days, by year
YearDateBirthsControl mean% of control
1994September 58,37811,55272.5
1995September 48,44111,53073.2
1996September 28,33111,56172.1
1997September 18,11611,32771.7
1998September 78,42811,59172.7
1999September 68,24911,67170.7
2000September 48,60312,25970.2
2001September 38,11512,37965.6
2002September 28,29712,53766.2
2003September 18,16412,70964.2
2004September 68,28112,55965.9
2005September 58,11612,96262.6
2006September 48,29813,37462.0
2007September 38,39713,58161.8
2008September 18,10513,41760.4
2009September 77,94713,05860.9
2010September 67,81512,49862.5
2011September 57,77012,53962.0
2012September 38,03012,73263.1
2013September 27,89612,55462.9
2014September 18,04312,67263.5

Control days: the same weekday one and two weeks before and after, inside the same year (four controls in every year). Total exposure: 84 control days for 21 holiday days.

Thanksgiving Day

Thanksgiving Day is the fourth Thursday in November, under the federal holiday rule published by the U.S. Office of Personnel Management. The dates below are derived from that rule in code.

Across the 21 years, Thanksgiving Day recorded 156,624 births where its control days averaged 262,307 over the same number of days: a ratio of 59.7% of the control level, a difference of 105,683 recorded births between the two sets of days. Year by year the ratio ranges from 54.0% to 69.2%, averaging 59.9%, and it is below the control level in 21 of 21 years. The difference is between two sets of recorded days.

Thanksgiving Day: births as a percentage of its matched control days, by year

Twenty-one columns, 1994 to 2014, each the holiday’s births against the mean of its same-weekday control days that year, with 100 drawn as a line.

Thanksgiving Day: births as a percentage of its matched control days, by yearTwenty-one columns, 1994 to 2014, each the holiday’s births against the mean of its same-weekday control days that year, with 100 drawn as a line.0204060801001994: 69.2%69.2%19941995: 68.4%1996: 66.7%1997: 66.5%19971998: 64.6%1999: 63.5%2000: 63.3%20002001: 60.0%2002: 58.4%2003: 58.1%20032004: 58.4%2005: 55.1%2006: 54.8%20062007: 54.5%2008: 54.7%2009: 54.0%54.0%20092010: 56.0%2011: 56.1%2012: 58.4%20122013: 57.8%2014: 59.9%100 = control days
Thanksgiving Day against matched control days, by year
YearDateBirthsControl mean% of control
1994November 248,03611,61269.2
1995November 237,75411,33468.4
1996November 287,77011,64166.7
1997November 277,68011,55766.5
1998November 267,65811,84964.6
1999November 257,52911,85463.5
2000November 238,14412,86963.3
2001November 227,51312,52960.0
2002November 287,39212,66258.4
2003November 277,34012,64058.1
2004November 257,61413,04658.4
2005November 247,26713,19155.1
2006November 237,52113,72254.8
2007November 227,56713,87554.5
2008November 277,12613,02054.7
2009November 266,86412,70654.0
2010November 257,16212,78656.0
2011November 246,89412,29556.1
2012November 227,26712,44658.4
2013November 287,17512,40757.8
2014November 277,35112,26859.9

Control days: the same weekday one and two weeks before and after, inside the same year (four controls in every year). Total exposure: 84 control days for 21 holiday days.

Method, in full

  1. Derive each year's holiday date from the OPM rule: first Monday in September, fourth Thursday in November.
  2. Take the U.S. daily birth count for that date from 85,712,738 recorded U.S. births on 7,670 calendar dates, 1994–2014.
  3. Take the same weekday at −14, −7, +7 and +14 days, within the same calendar year. Drop any control that is itself one of the studied holidays.
  4. Compare the holiday count with the mean of its controls, as a ratio. The figures reported are the observed ratio, its year-by-year range and the number of years below the control level, which is what 21 paired observations support.

What this shows

This is a matched calendar comparison. It identifies an association between these holiday dates and lower recorded daily counts. Scheduling of inductions and caesareans, staffing, and registration or reporting practice are all consistent with the pattern. The range quoted is the variation across years.

Because these holidays move, a date such as September 4 was Labor Day in some of the 21 years, so part of its total is inside this comparison. Its own page says how many years that was.

Check your own birthday → · The quietest dates overall

Sources, method and limits

Holiday rule: U.S. Office of Personnel Management, federal holidays. Birth counts: 85,712,738 recorded U.S. births on 7,670 calendar dates, 1994–2014, CDC/NCHS and SSA daily counts via FiveThirtyEight (CC BY 4.0).

Every figure above comes from the administrative records named here, at the granularity those records publish: a day, a month or a year. Coverage and definitions differ between countries and eras, so two sources are combined only where their documentation states the windows are separate, and the page where that happens says so.

Full method, leap-day treatment and definitions.

Want the data? Ask for it.